Timinator

10-21-2008, 11:49 AM

I've recently been working on using Cg geometry shaders for generating point sprites rather using than ARB sprites. In order to have the sprites be in "world space" rather than screen space, I'm doing the MVP multiplication in the geometry shader like so:

POINT

TRIANGLE_OUT

void SpriteGeomProg(

AttribArray<float4> pos : POSITION,

AttribArray<float2> params : TEXCOORD0, //x=width, y=height

uniform float3 world_up,

uniform float3 eye_right )

{

// Expand point into vertically alligned quad

const float4 pos1 = mul( glstate.matrix.mvp, pos[0] + float4( -eye_right * params[0].x, 1.f ) );

const float4 pos2 = mul( glstate.matrix.mvp, pos[0] + float4( eye_right * params[0].x, 1.f ) );

const float4 pos3 = mul( glstate.matrix.mvp, pos[0] + float4( eye_right * params[0].x + world_up * params[0].y, 1.f ) );

const float4 pos4 = mul( glstate.matrix.mvp, pos[0] + float4( -eye_right * params[0].x + world_up * params[0].y, 1.f ) );

emitVertex( pos1: POSITION );

emitVertex( pos2: POSITION );

emitVertex( pos3: POSITION );

emitVertex( pos3: POSITION );

emitVertex( pos1: POSITION );

emitVertex( pos4: POSITION );

}

The problem I'm seeing is that it appears as though the depth testing against other elements in the scene is not working as expected. While the sprites occlude one another, they are not occluded by other objects in the scene. The ARB point sprites did not behave this way. Also, if I perform the MVP multiplication in the vertex program, there is no problem.

Is there a problem with doing the MVP multiplication in the geometry shader in this way?

POINT

TRIANGLE_OUT

void SpriteGeomProg(

AttribArray<float4> pos : POSITION,

AttribArray<float2> params : TEXCOORD0, //x=width, y=height

uniform float3 world_up,

uniform float3 eye_right )

{

// Expand point into vertically alligned quad

const float4 pos1 = mul( glstate.matrix.mvp, pos[0] + float4( -eye_right * params[0].x, 1.f ) );

const float4 pos2 = mul( glstate.matrix.mvp, pos[0] + float4( eye_right * params[0].x, 1.f ) );

const float4 pos3 = mul( glstate.matrix.mvp, pos[0] + float4( eye_right * params[0].x + world_up * params[0].y, 1.f ) );

const float4 pos4 = mul( glstate.matrix.mvp, pos[0] + float4( -eye_right * params[0].x + world_up * params[0].y, 1.f ) );

emitVertex( pos1: POSITION );

emitVertex( pos2: POSITION );

emitVertex( pos3: POSITION );

emitVertex( pos3: POSITION );

emitVertex( pos1: POSITION );

emitVertex( pos4: POSITION );

}

The problem I'm seeing is that it appears as though the depth testing against other elements in the scene is not working as expected. While the sprites occlude one another, they are not occluded by other objects in the scene. The ARB point sprites did not behave this way. Also, if I perform the MVP multiplication in the vertex program, there is no problem.

Is there a problem with doing the MVP multiplication in the geometry shader in this way?